Skip to Content

Virgin Piña Colada Recipe

Virgin Piña Colada Recipe

Share to Your Social Media

I was a waitress at one of the most exclusive hotels in the world. I met many celebrities; Bill Gates, Katy Perry, Anne Hathaway, Susan Somers, Russell Brand, world leaders, famous entrepreneurs, etc. Each hotel room cost on average $2,500 a night and with gratuity, dining, room service, etc. it ended up being about $4,000 a night per couple. Some rooms were over $5,000 a night!

I mainly served food and our bar tender made the drinks. Sometimes during the day or nights, she wasn’t there I’d have orders that I’d need to make. Many times I had to make the guests either a virgin or a regular Piña Colada. Whenever I did I either got a compliment like, “That is the BEST Piña Colada I have ever tasted!” or they would simply order another and the next day another and the next day another. They never seemed to be able to get enough of it.

How did I craft this recipe? It all started at a local small restaurant in Playa Del Carmen, Mexico called El Pirate. The first time dining there the Piña Colada I ordered was to die for. I watched as they made it. The next day I couldn’t wait to have it again so I ordered another. I watched as a different server made it. I noticed that the server making it was using different ingredients and ratios than the one the day before.

The results were disappointing. The next day (yes I was a little stuck on El Pirate) and I tried again. It was a different server so again we left a little disappointed in our Piña Colada. As a result, I came away with a few tips on how to make a great and not so great virgin Piña Colada.

When we got home we kept talking about that ‘Amazing Piña Colada’. So to satisfy our cravings I set out trying to make it. One day I struck gold and I was more than a little excited to finally taste an amazing Piña Colada again. It was pretty much just like the first one that started this quest at El Pirate.

I hope you enjoy this recipe as much as we and others I’ve made it for have!

It takes 10-15 minutes

Serves 2-4 people (depending on the size of glass)

Fine-Dining-Tested, Celebrity-Approved: My Pina Colada

Ingredients:
1 1/2 Cup medium sized chopped chunks of Ripe Pineapple
1 1/2 Tablespoon Orange Juice concentrate (secret ingredient)
1/2 can or 3/4 Cup Coco Lopez Cream of Coconut (this can usually be found in the Hispanic food or drink isles at the grocery store or here)
Ice

Fine-Dining-Tested, Celebrity-Approved: My Pina Colada

1. VERY IMPORTANT. First, you need to pour the whole can of the Coco Lopez into a bowl and mix it with a spoon because the coconut oil and other ingredients separate.

2. Put the first 3 items in a blender. Then fill the blender up with ice (3/4 full). Blend well.

3. TASTE TEST depending on taste preferences and how much ice you put in it, it may be too rich or even possibly taste a little diluted. If it is too rich add another cup of ice and blend again. If it is diluted add another chunk of pineapple and a Tablespoon of Coco Lopez and blend again. Filling the ice about 3/4 full usually works great for a standard size blender.

By the way, if you are on the market for a new blender, definitely check out Blendtec, I just got one and LOVE it!
And just in case you didn’t know, Blendtec has refurbished 7-year warrantied blenders with free shipping! They are highly rated and about 40% off too!

Fine-Dining-Tested, Celebrity-Approved: My Pina Colada

4- Enjoy! This seriously is the best Piña Colada I and many other celebrities have ever had!

Fine-Dining-Tested, Celebrity-Approved: My Pina Colada

Virgin Piña Colada Recipe

Virgin Piña Colada Recipe

Yield: 2-4
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 15 minutes

This seriously is the best Piña Colada I and many other celebrities have ever had!

Ingredients

  • 1 1/2 Cup medium sized chopped chunks of Ripe Pineapple
  • 1 1/2 Tablespoon Orange Juice concentrate (secret ingredient)
  • 1/2 can or 3/4 Cup Coco Lopez Cream of Coconut (this can usually be found in the Hispanic food or drink isles at the grocery store or here)
  • Ice

Instructions

  1. VERY IMPORTANT. First you need to pour the whole can of the Coco Lopez into a bowl and mix it with a spoon because the coconut oil and other ingredients separate.
  2. Put the first 3 items in a blender. Then fill the blender up with ice (3/4 full). Blend well.
  3. TASTE TEST depending on taste preferences and how much ice you put in it, it may be too rich or even possibly taste a little diluted. If it is too rich add another cup of ice and blend again. If it is diluted add another chunk of pineapple and a Tablespoon of Coco Lopez and blend again. Filling the ice about 3/4 full usually works great for a standard size blender.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest


 Save Big + Free Shipping on Blendtec Certified Refurbished Blenders by clicking here.

The Best Piña Colada Recipe

For other ‘rich living tips’ please subscribe, like me on Facebook, and follow me on Pinterest and Instagram.

Fine-Dining-Tested, Celebrity-Approved: My Pina Colada

 

 

SUBSCRIBE FOR OUR EMAILS 

PLUS, get our Free Financial Fitness Boot Camp...

Lisa

Saturday 28th of May 2016

Drank this while pregnant, by our pool, AMAZING! Will be making these again for the memorial day weekend, have several nondrinkers coming, this is the perfect recipe!

Anita Fowler

Tuesday 31st of May 2016

Awe I'm so glad!!! Thanks for leaving a review!

Great Ideas -- 19 Ice Creams, Popsicles, and Frozen Treats!

Saturday 11th of July 2015

[…] Virgin Pina Colada @ Live Like You Are Rich […]

The Best Slow Cooker Fajita Recipe | Live Like You Are Rich

Thursday 14th of May 2015

[…] de Mayo for my family who all said they were fantastic. I paired them with my ‘famous’ Pina Coladas and the best gauc ever! You can find the recipes in this […]

Emilee

Saturday 2nd of May 2015

Is the Coco Creme supposed to be semi solid when you first open it? Ours seems to be.

Anita Fowler

Saturday 2nd of May 2015

Yes you pour it into a bowl and mix it well because it separates.

Beth

Wednesday 22nd of April 2015

This looks so good! I plan to try it this weekend, but our Walmart didn't have the cream of coconut, only the canned coconut milk--is this the same thing? Where else should I look?

Anita Fowler

Monday 27th of April 2015

Beth they should have it. I've seen it in every store I've been in. It is either in the alcholic mixer area or the Hispanic food area. I'm sorry you couldn't find it. Coconut milk is NOT the same thing. I'm sorry! This is Cream of coconut.

//z-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/onejs?MarketPlace=US&adInstanceId=f0b4d8e9-228f-4af2-afbc-69062252466b
//z-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/onejs?MarketPlace=US&adInstanceId=f0b4d8e9-228f-4af2-afbc-69062252466bSkip to Recipe